Root HR
← Price notes

The cost of getting it wrong: fines small employers can avoid

15 November 2026 · 3 min read · Root HR

HR manager comparing paper records with a tablet in an office

When small employers think about the cost of HR software, they compare it with doing nothing. But doing nothing has a price too. It just arrives later, and all at once.

This post looks at the penalties a small UK employer is most likely to face, using official and sourced figures, and at how good records help you avoid them.

Illegal working: up to £45,000 per worker

If you employ someone who does not have the right to work in the UK, the Home Office can issue a civil penalty. Since 13 February 2024 the maximum is £45,000 per worker for a first breach and £60,000 per worker for a repeat breach (GOV.UK codes of practice). A new code of practice came into force on 1 October 2026, and the amounts did not change.

That is per worker. Two workers on one visit is a six-figure risk for a business that might turn over less than that in a year.

The protection is simple: a correct right to work check, done before the job starts and kept on file, gives you a "statutory excuse" if the worker later turns out to have no right to work (GOV.UK employer's guide). The key words are "kept on file". If you cannot show the check, it did not happen.

Follow-up checks matter as much as the first one. A worker with time-limited permission needs checking again before it ends. That date is easy to lose in a spreadsheet.

Sponsor licences: revocations at record levels

If you sponsor workers, losing your licence can cost you far more than a fine. The Home Office revoked 261 sponsor licences in the year to June 2022 (Home Office). In the year to June 2026, 4,403 Skilled Worker licences were revoked, according to Home Office data reported by the Work Rights Centre.

Sponsors also have reporting deadlines. Many changes, such as a sponsored worker leaving or a cut to their salary, must be reported within 10 working days. Missing them is the kind of slip that shows up on a compliance visit.

Payroll: late reports to HMRC

Each time you pay staff, you must report the payment to HMRC through Real Time Information (GOV.UK). If reports are late, HMRC can charge a monthly penalty. It is £100 a month for 1 to 9 employees, £200 for 10 to 49, £300 for 50 to 249 and £400 for 250 or more (GOV.UK).

For a small team, £100 or £200 a month adds up quickly over a busy season when payroll slips.

Minimum wage: arrears, fines and being named

Not paying the National Minimum Wage is a criminal offence. Arrears must be paid back straight away, there is a fine on top, and employers can be named by the government (GOV.UK).

Underpayment is often an accident: unpaid time at the start of a shift, or a rate not updated after the April rise. From 1 April 2026 the National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over is £12.71 an hour (GOV.UK). You must also keep pay records for at least six years.

What all of these have in common

Every penalty above comes back to records. Did you do the check? When? Is the visa still valid? Was the payroll report sent? What was this person paid, and for how many hours?

A business with clear, dated records can answer those questions in minutes. A business without them is guessing, and the fine is the cost of the guess.

Where Root HR fits

Root HR keeps the record so you are not relying on memory:

  • Right to work documents saved on each staff record, with the date.
  • Visa and document expiry dates, with reminders before they pass.
  • Sponsor compliance records, with reminders of reporting deadlines.
  • Clock-in and rota hours that flow into payroll, which is sent to HMRC.

You still carry out the right to work check and make any Home Office reports yourself. Root HR reminds you and keeps the history.

All of it is included from £120 a year, excluding VAT, for up to 15 employees. Set that against a single £45,000 penalty and the sums are not hard. Book a free 30-minute demo or see more at roothr.co.uk.

See Root HR in 30 minutes

HR, rota, leave, payroll and sponsor compliance records in one place, from £10 a month.

Book a free demo