Per-employee pricing explained: how to compare quotes

Most HR software is priced per employee per month. It sounds simple. Multiply the price by your headcount and you have your answer.
In practice, two quotes with the same per-employee price can end up hundreds of pounds apart by the end of the year. Here is why, and how to compare them properly.
Step 1: find out what one "employee" includes
Before you compare prices, compare what each price buys. A low figure that covers records and leave only is not the same product as one that also covers rotas, clock-in and payroll.
Make a short list of what your business needs. Then, for each quote, tick off what is in the per-employee price and what costs more. Only compare like with like.
Step 2: check the minimum
Many plans bill a minimum number of employees. If the minimum is 15 and you have 8 staff, you pay for 15.
That is not a trick, but it changes the maths. Work out the price on the number you will actually be billed for, not the number on your payroll.
Step 3: work out the yearly total
Monthly figures hide the size of the commitment. Turn every quote into a yearly total, excluding VAT, so you are comparing the same thing.
- Yearly billing: the yearly invoice.
- Monthly billing: the monthly invoice times 12.
Then add any set-up fees and any add-ons you ticked in step 1.
Step 4: model your growth
Ask what happens when you add five people, then ten. Some prices rise smoothly. Others jump when you cross a band. A tool that is cheap at 12 staff can be expensive at 30.
Write down the cost of each extra employee, and check where any bundles or bands start.
Step 5: divide back down
Now take each yearly total, divide by 12, and divide by the number of employees billed. That is your true price per employee per month. It is often quite different from the figure on the website.
A worked example
Here is how Root HR's own prices run through these steps. All prices exclude VAT, and every feature is included in every plan, payroll too.
The yearly Starter plan is £120 a year for up to 15 employees. Each employee over 15 adds £10 a year. Monthly billing is £14 a month for up to 15, plus £1.50 a month per extra employee.
A team of 8. Every plan bills at least 15 employees, so the team is billed as 15.
- Yearly: £120 a year.
- Monthly: £14 x 12 = £168 a year.
A team of 15.
- Yearly: £120 a year. That is £10 a month, or about £0.67 per employee per month.
- Monthly: £168 a year, or about £0.93 per employee per month.
A team of 25.
- Yearly: £120 plus 10 extra employees at £10, which is £220 a year. That works out at about £0.73 per employee per month.
- Monthly: £14 plus 10 extra employees at £1.50, which is £29 a month, or £348 a year.
Larger teams move onto bundles. 50 employees is £588 a year or £59 a month. 100 employees is £1,068 a year or £99 a month.
You can see two things straight away. Yearly billing costs less than monthly for the same team. And the per-employee figure moves with team size, so always work it out on your own numbers.
Questions to ask every supplier
- What is in this per-employee price, and what costs extra?
- Is there a minimum number of employees billed?
- Is payroll included?
- What does each extra employee cost?
- Is there a set-up fee or a minimum contract term?
- Are prices shown with or without VAT?
If a supplier cannot answer these in a few lines, that tells you something too.
Next step
Run each quote you have through the five steps above. If you would like us to run Root HR's numbers for your exact team size, and show you what the price covers, book a free 30-minute demo or visit roothr.co.uk.
HR, rota, leave, payroll and sponsor compliance records in one place, from £10 a month.
Book a free demo